Real Estate

Co-ops

Buying a New York co-op means purchasing shares and a proprietary lease rather than a deed, and Fisher Stone handles the closing for a flat fee.

Co-ops at Fisher Stone
  • Handles Co-op purchases and sales
  • You buy Shares, not real property
  • Board Application and interview required
  • Pricing Flat fee, quoted up front

What's included

Everything your flat fee covers

  • A free, roughly 15-minute consultation and a flat-fee quote up front
  • Review of the offering plan, board minutes, and financial statements
  • Preparation of your board package and application materials
  • Negotiation and review of the proprietary lease and purchase agreement
  • Coordination with your lender on the share loan and recognition agreement
  • Attorney attendance and representation at the closing

When you buy a cooperative apartment in New York, you are buying shares in the corporation that owns the building, along with a proprietary lease giving you the right to occupy your apartment, rather than buying real property directly. That share structure is the foundation of the transaction, and it shapes the financing, the closing documents, the board’s role, and how you eventually sell.

Fisher Stone represents buyers and sellers of cooperative apartments across New York City, Westchester County, and New Rochelle. Your attorney reviews the offering plan, board minutes, and financial statements before you sign, prepares your board package, and coordinates your share loan through closing, all for a flat fee, quoted up front after a short, free consultation. A licensed New York attorney handles your purchase or sale from contract to closing, reachable by call, email, or text, with no call center and no handoffs.

What you own when you buy a co-op

A cooperative building belongs to a corporation, and buying a co-op is a transfer of shares and a lease assignment, not a transfer of real property. The purchase is governed by the rules that apply to personal property rather than the rules that apply to a deed, and the closing documents reflect that: instead of a deed, you receive a stock certificate and an assignment of the proprietary lease, along with the co-op’s own transfer forms and any consents the building requires.

Financing works differently too. Since there is no real property to secure a mortgage against, a lender finances a co-op purchase with a share loan, secured by your shares and lease rather than the apartment itself, and the co-op’s board typically signs a recognition agreement acknowledging the lender’s rights before the loan can close. Fisher Stone also represents banks and private lenders on New York transactions, including co-op share loans. See our lender and bank representation page for that side of a closing.

Co-op purchases are one part of Fisher Stone’s broader residential real estate practice, which also covers condominiums and houses. If you are weighing a co-op against a condo, the table below compares the two, plus a house, at a glance.

 Co-opCondoHouse
What you ownShares in the cooperative corporation, plus a proprietary leaseReal property, by deedThe land and the building, by deed
Board approvalUsually required, often including an interviewBoard typically has a right of first refusal, but full approval is uncommonNot applicable, no board
FinancingA share loan, secured by the shares and the leaseA conventional mortgage, secured by the unitA conventional mortgage, secured by the property
Typical closing costsGenerally no mortgage recording tax, since the loan is a share loan, but may include a flip tax the co-op setsSimilar to a house, plus review of the offering plan and bylawsTransfer taxes, a mortgage recording tax on a new loan, and standard title and recording charges

The board application and interview

Most cooperative buildings require board approval before a purchase can close. The process starts with a board package: an application, financial disclosures, reference letters, and often several years of tax returns and bank statements. Many buildings also require an interview with a member or committee of the board before it votes on the application.

A cooperative board can decline an applicant for almost any reason and generally does not have to explain its decision, which is why board approval remains a real contingency even after a contract is signed. Within that discretion, a board cannot base its decision on race, religion, national origin, disability, familial status, or other legally protected characteristics. Fisher Stone cannot predict how a specific board will rule, but we prepare your board package to present your application as clearly and completely as the building’s process allows.

What your attorney reviews before you sign

Before you sign a contract, your attorney reviews the co-op’s offering plan, board minutes, and financial statements. The offering plan describes how the building is structured as a cooperative and what rights and restrictions attach to the shares. Board minutes record what the board has discussed and decided, and the financial statements show the building’s income, expenses, and reserves. Together, these documents can reveal:

  • An assessment that is already in place, or one the board has discussed for upcoming repairs or capital projects
  • Pending or threatened litigation involving the building, the board, or the sponsor
  • The balance and maturity date of the co-op’s underlying mortgage, the loan the corporation itself carries on the building
  • How much the building holds in reserve relative to its ongoing obligations

Any of these can affect whether the purchase makes sense at the price offered, and your attorney raises what the review turns up before you sign.

Maintenance charges, flip taxes, and other co-op costs

Maintenance charges compared to condo common charges

Maintenance is the co-op’s monthly bill to each shareholder. It typically covers building operating costs (staff, insurance, common-area utilities, and repairs), plus the building’s real estate taxes and debt service on its underlying mortgage, since the corporation, not the shareholder, holds that loan. A condominium has no underlying mortgage and no single tax bill: each owner pays their own real estate taxes and carries their own mortgage, so common charges cover only operating costs, with no tax or debt service folded in. That is why maintenance and common charge figures are not directly comparable between a co-op and a condo of similar size.

Flip taxes and other transfer fees

Many New York City co-ops also charge a flip tax when shares change hands, on top of the government transfer taxes on any residential sale. A flip tax is set by the co-op itself, not by law, so it varies by building: some calculate it as a share of the sale price, others as a share of profit, others as a flat amount. Whether your building has one is set out in the proprietary lease or house rules. Co-ops may also charge separate application fees and move-in or move-out deposits. Your attorney identifies these charges and confirms the figures for your building.

Sublet and pied-a-terre restrictions

Most proprietary leases restrict subletting. Some buildings prohibit it outright, others allow it only after the shareholder has owned and occupied the apartment for a minimum period, and most require board approval for each sublet along with a limit on how many years the unit can be rented before the owner returns to occupy it or sells. Some buildings also restrict or prohibit pied-a-terre ownership, expecting the apartment to be a shareholder’s primary residence rather than an occasional-use second home.

These restrictions matter most to buyers who anticipate relocating for work, buying with a family member who will not live there full time, or wanting the flexibility to rent the unit out later. A condominium generally imposes fewer restrictions on subletting and non-primary use, since a condo owner holds real property outright. Buyers planning mainly a rental investment should also see our real estate investors page. Your attorney reviews the lease and house rules for these restrictions on every co-op purchase.

Selling a co-op

Selling a co-op involves the same board approval process from the other side. Once you have a signed contract, the buyer submits a purchase application and financial disclosures to the board, which reviews and interviews the buyer under the same standards it applies to any applicant. The sale cannot close until the board approves the incoming buyer, so a seller’s timeline depends partly on how quickly the board schedules its review.

Your attorney prepares the seller’s side of the closing: responding to the buyer’s attorney’s requests, confirming payoff of any loan secured by your shares, and coordinating the transfer of your shares and the lease assignment once the board approves the sale. Fisher Stone represents sellers on this side of the transaction as part of its broader real estate practice, alongside condo and house sales, commercial transactions, and lender representation.

How it works

How Fisher Stone handles your co-op purchase

  1. Free consultation and document review

    After a short, free consultation, we quote a flat fee for your purchase. Your attorney then requests and reviews the offering plan, recent board minutes, and the co-op's financial statements.

  2. Board package and approval

    Your attorney helps assemble your board package and financial disclosures, submits the application, and prepares you for the board interview.

  3. Closing

    Once the board approves your purchase, your attorney coordinates the share loan closing, reviews the closing documents with you, and represents your interests at the closing table.

Working with a Fisher Stone attorney

Why Fisher Stone

What you can expect on every matter

  • 01Direct access to your attorneyWork with the attorney on your matter, not a call center. Reach them by call, email, or text.
  • 02Flat-fee pricing, quoted up frontOne flat fee before any work begins, so you know the full cost of your matter in advance.
  • 03No handoffsThe attorney you meet drafts your documents and sees your matter through to the end.

Questions

FAQs on Co-ops

What am I actually buying when I purchase a co-op?

When you buy a co-op, you are buying shares in the cooperative corporation that owns the building, along with a proprietary lease that gives you the right to occupy your specific apartment, rather than a deed to real property. That means the purchase is governed by the rules that apply to personal property, and it affects the closing documents, the loan you use to finance the purchase, and how you eventually sell.

Can a co-op board reject a buyer?

Yes. A cooperative board can decline an applicant for almost any reason and generally does not have to explain its decision. The board cannot base a rejection on race, religion, national origin, disability, familial status, or other legally protected characteristics, but within those limits it has wide discretion over who it approves to live in the building.

What does my attorney look for in the co-op's financial statements and board minutes?

Your attorney reviews the offering plan, recent board minutes, and the co-op's financial statements before you sign a contract. These documents can reveal a pending or planned assessment, ongoing litigation involving the building, the balance and maturity of the co-op's underlying mortgage, and how much the building holds in reserve. Any of these can affect whether the purchase makes sense and what questions to raise before you commit.

How is financing a co-op different from a conventional mortgage?

Because you are buying shares and a proprietary lease rather than real property, a lender finances a co-op purchase with a share loan, secured by your shares and lease instead of a conventional mortgage on the apartment. The co-op's board typically has to sign a recognition agreement acknowledging the lender's rights, and your attorney coordinates this process with your lender as part of the closing.

What is a flip tax?

A flip tax is a transfer fee that some cooperative corporations charge when shares change hands, separate from the government transfer taxes that apply to any residential sale. It is set by the co-op itself rather than by law, so it varies by building and may be calculated as a share of the price, a share of the profit, or a flat amount. Your attorney identifies whether your building has a flip tax and confirms the figures that apply to your transaction.

Can I rent out my co-op apartment or use it as a pied-a-terre?

That depends on the building. Many co-ops restrict subletting, allowing it only after a minimum period of owner occupancy and only with board approval for a limited term, and some restrict or prohibit non-primary residence ownership altogether. Your attorney reviews the proprietary lease and house rules for these restrictions before you sign a contract, so you know the building's limits before you are bound to buy.

How do I get started?

Call (212) 256-1877 for a free consultation of about 15 minutes to describe your co-op purchase or sale. After that call, we quote a flat fee for the work so you know the full cost before we begin, and a licensed attorney handles the matter from there through closing.

(212) 256-1877 Book a consultation

Book a consultation

Fill out the form and a licensed New York attorney will review your matter.

Loading the form. Open it in a new tab

Submitting does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prefer to talk? (212) 256-1877